The other morning, I had one of those moments that took me right back to high school. Parked side by side in the lot my office shares with the transmission shop next door were a 1961 Ford Galaxie and a 1980 Buick Regal.
Just as it would have back then, my attention immediately went to the big old Ford. Even in the early 1980s, the Galaxie already looked like it belonged to another era—which, of course, it did. Although it was only about 20 years old at the time, it felt as old then as it is now but still had a cool, "American Graffiti" vibe the then-"modern" Regal couldn't come to matching. That's not to say the Regal was especially modern, either. Even by 1980 standards, it was more evolutionary than revolutionary.
On paper, though, the two cars have more in common than you might expect. Both are rear-wheel-drive, V-8-powered, body-on-frame, two-door coupes. Their suspension designs differ in the details, but philosophically they're cut from the same live rear axle.
The Regal is unquestionably the better handler, thanks in large part to weighing roughly 400 to 500 pounds less than the Ford. Still, it's no sports car.
The size difference is obvious. The Galaxie stretches about 210 inches long and 79 inches wide, while the Regal measures roughly 200 inches in length and 70 inches in width. The Buick's relatively short 108-inch wheelbase exaggerates its compact appearance; this is not a small car.
By comparison, the Galaxie's expansive 119-inch wheelbase gave Ford's designers room to indulge in the dramatic proportions and sweeping lines that defined the era. If ever there were a case of form taking precedence over function, you're looking at it.
Even today, this now (gulp) 46-year-old Buick probably wouldn't draw many glances in a high school parking lot. As one of GM's downsized A/G-body intermediates built from 1978 to 1987, I've never been fond of their soulless, appliance-like styling. That goes double if not triple for their interiors.
Big Fords from this era don't row my land yacht, either, but parked next to the Regal, the Galaxie has all the charisma of Fonzie. The Buick? Let's just say it's more Mr. Furley. Side bar, the heck is going on with these massive rear tires?
To be fair, Ford's designers and engineers in the late 1950s weren't burdened by the safety, emissions, and fuel economy regulations that shaped cars like the Regal two decades later. Those constraints inevitably influenced styling, packaging, and engineering.
General Motors did a much better job designing their similarly proportioned 1968 to 1979 "compact" X-body Chevrolet Nova, Pontiac Ventura er al.
Riding the wave of America's fascination with the Space Race, Ford introduced the "Galaxie" name as a top trim level on the 1959 Fairlane. Beginning in 1960 through 1974, the Galaxie became a standalone full-size model.
Buick kept the Regal name around much longer. It debuted as an upscale trim level on the all-new midsize Century for 1973 before becoming its own model in 1974. The Regal remained in Buick's lineup through 2004, after which it was effectively replaced by the LaCrosse. Buick revived the Regal for the 2011 model year as a rebadged Opel Insignia, and it remained in production through 2020.